Ssshhhhhh, I’m Huntin’ Wabbits!

 

I used to think mathematics is about as straight forward as you can get; a thing is a thing and it’s always that thing.  But I long ago realized that there is art in play.  Certain observations have a mark of individuality.  I guess I shouldn’t be surprised at all that law is the same way.

There is an art.

And here, via Althouse, is one artist taking another to school:

Paul Clement will attack the expansion of Medicaid. He’s talking about whether it’s “coercive,” because if it is, it won’t fit the Spending Power. Justice Kagan wants to know why a “big gift from the Federal Government” is coercion. “The Federal Government is here saying, we are giving you a boatload of money.” Page 3. Just a big old boatload of money is coercive, Clement says confidently. But the actual bill has a “very big condition.” Kagan interrupts, trying to make her point that a big boatload of money is not coercive. What if someone offered you a job and would pay you $10 million a year. Of course, you say yes, but you’re not coerced are you. Clement lays down one of the cleverist teasers I have ever heard: “Well, I guess I would want to know where the money came from.”

“Wow. Wow.” says Kagan. Has a Supreme Court ever said “Wow. Wow” before? She can’t believe you’d do anything other than snap up that money. “I’m offering you $10 million a year to come work for me, and you are saying that this is anything but a great choice?”

Clement springs his trap: “Sure, if I told you, actually, it came from my own bank account.”

Beautiful.  And somewhat ballsy.

I suspect that Supreme Court Justices don’t enjoy being mocked in court.  But hey, style points none the less.

The lesson, of course, is that the Liberal doesn’t know the money is already mine.

3 responses to “Ssshhhhhh, I’m Huntin’ Wabbits!

  1. I’m too tapped out for a another meaty comment; but is it wabbit season or duck season?

  2. How’s the self-hosting going?

    I wondered why you and the poison boys didn’t go self-hosted, but on WordPress.

    I miss being able to have comments and your and other reactions in one place with discussions with other bloggers on WordPress. On the other hand I supposed it forces me to to your place, and that must be the upside.

    • How’s the self-hosting going?

      I like it. But I think that’s the geek in me.

      I wondered why you and the poison boys didn’t go self-hosted, but on WordPress.

      It used to be that tags and categories were global on WordPress. When they changed that to local I moved.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *